The 7-Point Checklist to Audit Backlinks and Eliminate 80% of Wasted Effort

Introduction

You’ve probably noticed it: your content looks solid, yet your site keeps hovering on page two of Google. You push out fresh articles every day, but your Authority Score (AS) doesn’t move.

This isn’t just about rankings. It means all your investment—time, money, and effort—might be wasted because you’re missing one final piece.

Your competitors somehow manage to get featured by industry sites and media, while you remain on the sidelines. That missing piece is backlinks—high-quality “votes of trust” from other websites.

The problem? Most people approach link building the wrong way.

In this article, we’ll reframe how you think about backlinks. Instead of obsessing over link quantity, you’ll learn how to focus on quality—the kind of links that move the needle.

---

Part 1: Three Types of Links

Before diving into backlink strategies, let’s clarify the basics:

1. Backlinks (Inbound Links)
   • Links from other sites pointing to yours.
   • These are the foundation of SEO authority and the focus of this article.
2. Outbound Links
   • Links from your site to external sources.
   • Useful for citing references and building trust with readers.
3. Internal Links
   • Links within your site connecting one page to another.
   • Helps both users and search engines navigate your content.

👉 In link building, we’re talking specifically about backlinks.

---

Part 2: Why Backlinks Matter — The Triple Value

A strong backlink delivers three distinct benefits:

1. 💎 Authority & Trust
   • Google’s E-E-A-T framework (Experience, Expertise, Authority, Trust) relies heavily on trusted sites endorsing you.
   • This credibility transfer is often called “link equity.”
2. 🎯 Relevance & Topical Authority
   • A link carries more weight if it comes from a site in your niche.
   • When multiple sites in the same field link to you, Google begins treating you as a topical authority.
3. 🚀 Referral Traffic
   • Good backlinks also bring real visitors, often highly targeted and more likely to convert.

---

Part 3: The 7-Point Link Quality Checklist

Key Metrics

• Authority Score (AS): The reputation of a domain.
• Page Authority Score (Page AS): The influence of the specific page linking to you.
• Pro Tip: Page-level authority is often more important than the domain’s overall score.

---

The Checklist

1. Reputation of the Source (AS & E-E-A-T)
   • Is the linking site credible in its field?
   • ⚠️ Low-authority sites add little to no SEO value.
2. Relevance of the Source
   • Does the site cover topics related to yours?
   • ⚠️ Irrelevant links can dilute your topical authority.
3. Page-Level Strength
   • Is the specific page high-quality and well-ranked?
   • ⚠️ A link from a strong domain but a weak page carries little weight.
4. Placement of the Link
   • Is it embedded naturally in the main content, or buried in a footer/sidebar?
   • ⚠️ Contextual links in the body text are far more valuable.
5. Anchor Text
   • Is the anchor text natural and relevant?
   • ⚠️ Over-optimized, keyword-stuffed anchors are a red flag for Google.
6. Link Type (Dofollow vs. Nofollow)
   • Does the link pass equity?
   • ⚠️ Sites that make all links nofollow provide limited SEO value.
7. Health of the Linking Site
   • Is the site’s backlink profile clean?
   • ⚠️ Links from spammy domains can harm your own reputation.

---

Part 4: The “Royalty” of Backlinks — .edu and .gov

Backlinks from universities (.edu) and government domains (.gov) are rare but extremely powerful. They carry natural authority, are non-commercial, and Google trusts them highly. One strong .edu link can be more valuable than dozens of regular blog mentions.

---

Part 5: Backlink Risks to Avoid

• PBNs (Private Blog Networks)
• Unlabeled Paid Links
• Link Farms / Spam Directories

Spotting Toxic Links with Semrush

• Use the Backlink Audit tool.
• Check the Toxicity Score.
• Watch for:
  • Penalized or unindexed domains
  • Sites spreading malware
  • Networks of spammy sites or PBNs

---

Part 6: Negative SEO Attacks

Competitors or bad actors may try to hurt your rankings by pointing large volumes of toxic links (often from porn, gambling, or spam sites) at your site. This is called a negative SEO attack.

---

Part 7: Using Google’s Disavow Tool Wisely

• When to Use It
  • Only if you’ve received a manual penalty for unnatural links
  • Or if you’re clearly under a large-scale negative SEO attack
• How to Use It
  • Prepare a .txt file listing the domains or URLs to disavow
  • Submit it through Google’s Disavow Tool

⚠️ In most cases, Google already ignores bad links automatically. Don’t overuse this tool.

---

Part 8: Two Link Building Models

1. The Pull Model (Earning Links)
   • Create high-value content such as guides, research, or free tools
   • Let others naturally link to you
2. The Push Model (Building Links)
   • Once you have value, proactively reach out
   • Share your content with sites and people who can benefit from it

---

Conclusion & Action Step

You now know how to evaluate link quality and avoid common traps.

👉 Your Task:

1. Open Semrush and study your biggest competitor’s backlink profile
2. Use the 7-point checklist to find their strongest link
3. Decide: would you earn that link via the Pull Model or secure it with the Push Model?

🔮 Next Up: How to build the cornerstone of the Pull Model—content so valuable others can’t ignore it.